Skip to content

How to find the best ISMS tool | 6clicks

Andrew Robinson |

June 6, 2023

How to find the best ISMS tool | 6clicks


When it comes to finding the best Information Security Management System (ISMS) tool, the process can often feel overwhelming due to the wide array of options available on the market. However, by following a systematic approach, you can ensure that you select the most suitable tool for your specific business requirements.

The first step in finding the best ISMS tool is to conduct thorough research. This involves exploring the various online tools available and understanding their key features, functionalities, and benefits. It is important to consider factors such as ease of use, compatibility with your existing systems, and the software's track record in terms of reliability and security.

Next, it is crucial to evaluate the different ISMS tools based on how well they align with your specific business requirements. Consider factors such as the size and nature of your organization, the complexity of your security management processes, and any specific compliance requirements that need to be addressed. This evaluation will help you narrow down the options and focus on the tools that are most likely to meet your needs.

Finally, it is important to take into account the feedback and experiences of other users. Look for reviews and testimonials from organizations that have implemented the ISMS tool you are considering. This will give you valuable insights into the tool's effectiveness, user-friendliness, and overall satisfaction among customers.

By following these steps of researching, evaluating, and considering specific business requirements, you can find the best ISMS tool that suits your organization's needs and helps you achieve effective information security management.

Mapping an ISMS to software

Mapping an Information Security Management System (ISMS) to software involves a systematic process to ensure that the software aligns with the requirements of the ISMS. This process consists of several steps to set up an effective ISMS using specialized software tools.

The first step in mapping an ISMS to software is defining the scope. This involves identifying the boundaries of the ISMS, determining the organizational units, processes, asset management, and setting the objectives of the ISMS. ISMS software provides the capability to define the scope and visualize it in a clear and structured manner.

Once the scope is defined, the next step is to gather information about the organization's business processes. This includes identifying the key activities, roles, responsibilities, and dependencies within the organization. ISMS software allows for the documentation and visualization of business processes, making it easier to capture and understand how information flows in the organization.

Furthermore, the software enables the capturing and linking of assets to each other. Assets can include physical devices, software, data, infrastructure, and human resources. ISMS software provides a comprehensive repository to capture and manage these assets, allowing for easy tracking and control.

One of the key components of ISMS software is the risk assessment module. This module enables organizations to identify and assess potential risks to their information security. It provides tools and methodologies to quantify and prioritize risks, helping organizations make informed decisions on risk mitigation strategies.

Moreover, ISMS software includes a risk treatment component that facilitates the implementation of controls and measures to mitigate identified risks. This component helps organizations monitor the effectiveness of risk treatment activities and track their progress towards reducing risks.

In conclusion, mapping an ISMS to software involves defining the scope, gathering business processes, and capturing assets within the software. ISMS software also provides comprehensive risk assessment and risk treatment functionalities, aiding organizations in the proactive management of information security risks.

What are the capabilities of really good ISMS software?

A really good ISMS software offers a wide array of capabilities to effectively manage information security. It enables organizations to define the scope of their ISMS, ensuring that the boundaries, objectives, and organizational units are clearly identified and documented. This software facilitates the management of interface requirements by capturing and visualizing the dependencies between key activities, roles, and responsibilities within the organization.

Moreover, the software provides robust asset setup and categorization functionalities. It allows organizations to capture and link various assets, including physical devices, software, data, infrastructure, and human resources. This comprehensive repository helps in easy tracking and control of assets.

A key component of this software is the risk assessment and treatment module. It supports organizations in identifying and assessing potential risks to their information security. It provides tools and methodologies to quantify and prioritize risks, enabling informed decision-making on risk mitigation strategies. The software also facilitates the implementation of controls and measures to mitigate identified risks and monitors the effectiveness of risk treatment activities.

Additionally, really good ISMS software encompasses task management capabilities, facilitating the assignment, tracking, and completion of security-related tasks. It also includes document control functionalities, ensuring effective management of documentation related to information security.

Furthermore, this software offers audit management and review support, allowing organizations to conduct internal audits, management reviews, vendor management and security policy reviews. It provides comprehensive reporting functionalities, enabling the generation of detailed reports on security incidents, compliance activities, and risk scores.

Some ISMS software might also offer optional modules such as data privacy management and business continuity management. These modules provide organizations with additional functionalities to address specific requirements related to privacy and business continuity.

How do the ISMS tools differ from each other?

ISMS tools differ from each other primarily in terms of their unique features, functionalities, capabilities, and pricing models. While all ISMS tools aim to assist organizations with security management systems and certification processes, they have varying degrees of effectiveness in addressing specific needs such as risk assessment, internal audits, and corrective actions.

Some ISMS tools offer comprehensive risk assessment modules that enable organizations to identify and assess potential risks to their information security. These tools provide tools and methodologies to quantify and prioritize risks, guiding informed decision-making on risk mitigation strategies. In contrast, other tools may have limited risk assessment capabilities or may require additional modules for this purpose.

Similarly, the ability to conduct internal audits and manage corrective actions can vary between ISMS tools. Some tools provide robust audit and review support, allowing organizations to conduct internal audits, management reviews, and security policy reviews. These tools offer comprehensive reporting functionalities to generate detailed reports on security incidents, compliance activities, and risk scores. On the other hand, other tools may have limited or basic audit and review capabilities.

Further differentiation can be seen in the pricing models of ISMS tools. Some tools may offer a subscription-based pricing model, allowing organizations to pay a monthly or annual fee for using the software. Other tools may adopt a per-user or per-module pricing approach, where organizations only pay for the specific functionalities they require.

Does it also work with Excel?

Setting up an effective Information Security Management System (ISMS) structure is crucial for organizations to protect their sensitive information. While some may consider using Excel as a tool for this purpose, it has several limitations that make it impractical.

One of the major difficulties in utilizing Excel for setting up an ISMS structure is maintaining data consistency. Excel lacks the built-in mechanisms to ensure that the data entered across different sheets, cells, or workbooks remain consistent. This can lead to discrepancies and inaccuracies in the information, compromising the integrity of the ISMS.

Linking individual elements together in Excel can also be challenging. Without dedicated features for data linking, it becomes cumbersome to establish and update relationships between different components of the ISMS. As a result, crucial information may be scattered across multiple sheets or workbooks, making it difficult to navigate and manage.

Another limitation is the rigid layout of rows and columns in Excel. When merging multiple structural elements, such as risk assessments, security policies, and compliance requirements, the fixed structure of Excel can be restrictive. It may require complex formulas or manual adjustments to accommodate the various components, making the overall structure difficult to maintain and update.

To overcome these limitations, organizations can turn to specialized ISMS tools. These tools provide convenient interfaces for capturing and linking data, ensuring data consistency and accuracy. They offer flexible structures that can adapt to the evolving needs of the ISMS, making it easier to manage and maintain. By leveraging ISMS tools, organizations can streamline their processes, enhance data integrity, and establish a robust foundation for information security management.

How do I find the right software for my business?

When it comes to finding the right software for your business, there are several factors you need to consider. First and foremost, you should evaluate your specific needs and requirements. Determine what functionality and features are essential for your business operations and processes. This will help you narrow down your options and focus on software solutions that align with your goals. Additionally, you should consider your budget and resources. Determine what you can afford and what type of support and training you may require. It's also important to research and read reviews about different software providers to ensure they have a reputable track record and a positive customer satisfaction rating. Lastly, it is beneficial to reach out to other businesses or industry professionals who have used similar software to get their recommendations and insights. By taking a systematic and informed approach, you can find the right software that will streamline your business processes and contribute to your overall success.

Project initiation

Project initiation is a crucial phase in implementing an Information Security Management System (ISMS). It sets the foundation for the entire project and ensures alignment with the organization's goals and objectives.

During the project initiation phase, it is important to clarify the current status and identify the problems or challenges faced by the organization in terms of information security. This helps in understanding the gaps and determining the scope of the ISMS implementation.

Next, a solution approach needs to be defined that addresses the identified problems and aligns with industry best practices and relevant ISO standards such as ISO 27001. This approach should consider the unique needs and requirements of the organization.

One key aspect of the project initiation phase is to highlight the benefits of implementing an ISMS. These benefits could include improved security posture, reduced risk of security incidents, enhanced compliance with regulations, increased stakeholder trust, and better decision-making based on reliable information.

Additionally, it is important to ascertain the organization's willingness and ability to carry out the project. This may involve engaging key stakeholders, assessing available resources, and determining organizational readiness for change.

Goals and scope should be clearly defined during this phase, outlining the specific objectives and the boundaries within which the project will operate. This helps in creating a shared understanding among project team members and ensures a focused approach.

Finally, a rough concept should be put together, highlighting the proposed approach, goals, scope, and anticipated outcomes. A comprehensive project plan should be created, outlining tasks, timelines, responsibilities, and resource requirements. This plan should be reviewed and refined as needed before seeking approval to proceed with the ISMS implementation project.

Definition of requirements

Defining the requirements for an Information Security Management System (ISMS) tool is a crucial step in the implementation process, as it ensures that the selected tool meets the specific needs of the organization.

To begin, the organization's general conditions must be taken into account. This includes factors such as the size and structure of the organization, its industry sector, the complexity of its information systems, and the level of security risks it faces. These conditions provide the context for the requirements gathering process.

Next, both business and technical requirements must be identified. Business requirements determine what the organization expects to achieve with the ISMS tool, such as improving efficiency, automating processes, enhancing communication, or aligning with industry standards. Technical requirements, on the other hand, define the technical capabilities and functionalities needed, such as integration with existing systems, access control features, reporting capabilities, scalability, and ease of use.

Compliance checklists are another essential consideration. These are derived from industry standards, regulatory requirements, and the organization's internal policies. The ISMS tool should have the necessary key features and functionalities to support ISO compliance activities, such as risk assessment, vendor risk management, internal audits, corrective actions, documentation management, incident management, and continuous monitoring.

Creating criteria and test catalogs is vital for the tool selection process. This involves determining the specific criteria that the ISMS tool must meet and developing a catalog of tests, such as functionality testing, usability testing, security testing, and performance testing. These tests help evaluate the suitability and effectiveness of the tool in meeting the organization's requirements.

Tool selection and evaluation

Tool selection and evaluation is a critical process that requires careful consideration and thorough analysis. It involves several steps to ensure that the chosen tool meets the organization's specific requirements and provides the desired benefits.

The first step is to create a longlist of potential tools. This can be done by researching and identifying various options available in the market. It is important to gather comprehensive information about each tool, including their features, functionalities, pricing, and customer reviews.

Once the longlist is created, the next step is to obtain detailed information from the product suppliers. This can be done through requests for proposals (RFPs) or requests for information (RFIs). These documents help in gathering specific information about the tools and assessing their suitability for the organization's needs.

Based on the information obtained, a shortlist of potential tools is created. This shortlist contains the most promising options that align with the organization's requirements.

The next step is to conduct proof of concept (POC) and trial versions of the shortlisted tools. This allows the organization to test the tools in real-world scenarios and evaluate their performance. It is important to assess factors such as usability, compatibility, security, and overall effectiveness during this stage.

After evaluating the POC and trial versions, the organization can narrow down the list further by selecting the most suitable tool providers. This can be done through a structured evaluation process, which may include scoring the tools based on predefined criteria.

The selected tool providers are then invited to present their offers and engage in negotiations. This provides an opportunity to clarify any doubts, negotiate pricing, and discuss support and maintenance.

Finally, based on the evaluation and negotiations, the organization makes a decision regarding the procurement and introduction of the selected tool.

For more guidance on tool selection and evaluation, you can refer to other 6clicks blogs that include useful resources like RFP and RFI templates, as well as vendor quick selection templates. These resources can streamline the tool selection process and ensure that all necessary factors are taken into account.

Excel criteria for tool selection

When it comes to selecting ISMS software, using Excel as a criteria for evaluation can have its challenges and limitations, especially when dealing with complex structures like asset inventory, asset registers and interlinked data. While Excel can be a useful tool for basic data management, it may not offer the robust capabilities required for effective information security management.

One limitation of using Excel for tool selection is the difficulty in maintaining data consistency. In complex ISMS systems, where there are multiple interdependencies and relationships between different data points, Excel may not provide convenient interfaces for capturing and linking data. This can result in errors, inconsistencies, and difficulties in analyzing and reporting on the data.

Additionally, Excel may not be equipped to handle the breadth of capabilities that dedicated ISMS tools offer. ISMS tools go beyond basic functions like data storage and provide features such as risk assessment, compliance management, incident management, and task management. These features are designed to streamline and automate various aspects of the information security management process, enhancing efficiency and effectiveness.

Therefore, while Excel can be a starting point for evaluating potential ISMS software, it is important to recognize its limitations when dealing with complex structures like asset inventory and interlinked data. Dedicated ISMS tools are specifically designed to maintain data consistency and provide convenient interfaces for capturing and linking data, ensuring the effectiveness of information security management processes.